*

*
November 20, 2026
Oakland Park, Florida
*
On November 18, 2026, the United States and Venezuela announced the signing of an agreement concerning military cooperation. American Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth and Venezuelan Defense Minister Gustavo González López signed the document in Caracas, in the presence of acting President Delcy Rodríguez. The Pentagon described its purpose as advancing cooperation and combined operations. Hegseth referred to joint training, intelligence sharing, and military capabilities. Neither government made the operative text available for public examination. The announcement established that representatives of the two governments had signed a document. It did not establish what authority each had exercised, what obligations had been undertaken, or what freedom Venezuela retained to reject the arrangement.1
A military cooperation agreement between sovereign states need not be objectionable. Governments share intelligence, train armed forces, exchange equipment, and establish procedures for addressing common security threats. Some operational provisions necessarily remain confidential. But operational confidentiality is different from withholding the authority under which one nation accepts another nation’s participation in its defense. The activities announced in Caracas concern powers through which a state protects its territory and determines the permissible presence and conduct of foreign military forces. Their legal character cannot be established by the announcement of cooperation alone.
The circumstances preceding the signature were not those of an ordinary bilateral relationship. On January 3, American forces entered Venezuela and removed Nicolás Maduro from power. On January 9, Trump announced that, because of Venezuela’s cooperation, he had cancelled a previously expected second wave of attacks, while American ships would remain in place. Later that day, he told petroleum executives that the second wave had been planned, described an American naval armada stationed off the coast, and said Venezuelan representatives had been “smart” and had done “the right thing.” He subsequently remarked that Venezuela could have been “obliterated” by one more strike. The intervening government had expressly connected its decision to withhold further military force to Venezuelan cooperation while maintaining the capacity to use that force.2
Those circumstances do not establish that every subsequent agreement was obtained through an unlawful threat. They establish the conditions under which Venezuela’s freedom of decision must be examined. A government negotiating after military intervention may possess lawful reasons to cooperate with the intervening power. It may also confront consequences for refusal that fundamentally alter the character of its acceptance. A declaration of consent does not distinguish between those possibilities. Whether the decision was independent depends upon the authority of the consenting officials, the commitments actually accepted, and the circumstances under which they were able to decide.
The petroleum agreement announced in August presents the problem through a different arrangement. According to the White House, Venezuela’s interim authorities granted North American Blue Energy Partners [NABEP] concessions over seventeen petroleum fields. The company separately entered into an agreement granting the United States government equity, preferential purchasing rights, and participation in corporate governance. The eighteen-page American partnership instrument examined by ProPublica bears the signatures of American officials and representatives of the private enterprise. Venezuela is not a party to that instrument. The authority by which Venezuelan officials granted the underlying concessions must therefore be established through a different act, one whose complete operative terms have not been made publicly available.3
The American government and the private corporation can undertake obligations toward each other without thereby establishing that Venezuela has lawfully granted every right upon which their arrangement depends. The corporation’s contractual promises may be clear while the Venezuelan authority supporting its concessions remains unexamined. The American agreement can determine relations among its own signatories. It cannot demonstrate, merely through their signatures, the independent sovereign decision upon which the company’s access to Venezuelan resources rests.
Nor does the designation of Venezuelan officials as an interim government settle the question. An official may occupy an office, exercise administrative powers, and participate in foreign negotiations while the extent of the authority to undertake particular commitments remains disputed. Article 12 of Venezuela’s Constitution declares mineral and hydrocarbon deposits to be inalienable and imprescriptible public property of the Republic; it does not itself prohibit lawful concessions for their exploitation. Article 150 of Venezuela’s Constitution requires National Assembly approval of national public-interest contracts in the cases determined by law, and separately requires that approval for public-interest contracts with foreign states, foreign official entities, or companies not domiciled in Venezuela. Whether the concessions meet those conditions cannot be established from the American partnership agreement. The constitutional power to dispose of national resources cannot be inferred solely from possession of an office, particularly when the obligations extend beyond the officials’ tenure. The relevant authority belongs to the Venezuelan constitutional order, not to the foreign government recognizing the officials who purport to exercise it.
Article 5 of Venezuela’s Constitution provides that sovereignty resides intransferably in the people, who exercise it directly as provided by the Constitution and law and indirectly, through suffrage, by the organs exercising public power. Those organs derive their authority from popular sovereignty and remain subject to it. The provision does not require a national referendum for every governmental agreement. It establishes that the official who signs an instrument exercises delegated authority rather than ownership of the sovereign power from which that authority proceeds.4
The Venezuelan nation is consequently not an external observer of these transactions. It is the constitutional source of the powers being exercised and the population whose resources, public finances, and security may be affected. A foreign government cannot establish the sufficiency of Venezuelan consent merely by identifying the Venezuelan officials with whom it has negotiated. Those officials must possess the authority required for the particular commitments undertaken. And the existence of that authority does not, by itself, determine whether its exercise was free from unlawful coercion.
The August petroleum announcement left both questions open. The White House described concessions extending for one hundred years, while Rodríguez characterized the bilateral project as lasting twenty-five years. ProPublica reported that the hundred-year figure did not appear in the American partnership agreement it examined. Different contractual rights were assigned different periods of operation and protection. These statements concern legally distinct instruments and cannot be reconciled simply by selecting one government’s preferred description. The extent of Venezuela’s own undertaking must be established from the Venezuelan grant.3
The disputed duration matters because a state may commit itself beyond the tenure of the government concluding an agreement. Such commitments are not inherently unlawful. Public borrowing, concessions, treaties, and commercial contracts regularly survive elections and changes of administration. But their duration gives greater consequence to the authority under which they were undertaken. The longer a commitment may constrain future decisions, the greater the need to establish what was authorized, by whom, under what conditions, and with what lawful means of revision or termination.
ProPublica also reported provisions intended to protect the enterprise against changes introduced by future American and Venezuelan governments. Investors have legitimate reasons to seek protection against arbitrary cancellation of contracts. That justification cannot establish the validity of the underlying Venezuelan grant or answer whether its terms were accepted freely. Protection of an investment presupposes rights lawfully obtained. It cannot independently demonstrate that the authority creating those rights possessed everything it purported to confer.
The military agreement of November 18 introduces an additional and more immediate dimension. Unlike the American partnership agreement with NABEP, the defense document was signed by representatives of both governments. There is therefore an acknowledged Venezuelan signature. But the public still lacks the text required to determine the obligations arising from it. A document announced as providing for combined operations may concern matters ranging from training arrangements to operational coordination involving foreign military personnel. Article 187(11) of Venezuela’s Constitution assigns the National Assembly authority to approve foreign military missions in the country. Article 154 generally requires Assembly approval of treaties before ratification, subject to specified exceptions. Whether the announced agreement engages either provision depends upon its legal character and the activities actually authorized. The announcement does not establish whether Venezuela retains the right to refuse participation in particular operations.
The presence of a Venezuelan signature answers the question of who purported to agree. It does not answer the question of what was agreed, and still less whether the agreement was obtained under conditions allowing an independent decision. That uncertainty is particularly consequential where the other signatory represents the armed forces that had intervened in the country months earlier. The prior intervention does not render every subsequent signature meaningless. It prevents the signature from being treated as sufficient evidence that coercion played no part in obtaining the arrangement.
Freedom to consent does not require equality of economic resources, military capabilities, or negotiating influence. States frequently enter agreements under unequal circumstances, and the smaller state may obtain genuine benefits through cooperation with a stronger one. But the stronger state had used military force against Venezuela, and its President publicly connected the cancellation of further attacks to Venezuelan cooperation. The ability to refuse cannot simply be presumed from the fact that officials eventually agreed. The intervening state must explain the relation between its exercise of military power and the commitments subsequently obtained.
Yet the documents necessary for examining that relation remain under the control of the governments and private parties that arranged the agreements. A member of the Venezuelan public seeking to determine the obligations imposed upon the country cannot examine the complete Venezuelan concession instrument. A citizen seeking to establish what military operations Venezuela has authorized cannot examine the newly signed defense document. The public is told that agreements exist and that cooperation has been accepted, but the evidence necessary to evaluate the scope and conditions of that acceptance is withheld.
The resulting difficulty is not an ordinary absence of information. It arises from decisions by the authorities who possess the documents. Those authorities may invoke the signatures as evidence of consent while denying the public access to the instruments in which consent is purportedly expressed. When the possibility of coercion is then challenged, the absence of publicly demonstrated coercion may be offered as reassurance. But the inquiry necessary to distinguish independent agreement from compelled acceptance has already been obstructed by withholding the evidence.
This reverses the responsibility for public justification. The Venezuelan population is placed in the position of having to demonstrate deficiencies in agreements it cannot read, while the officials exercising the disputed powers claim authority from documents they control. The absence of disclosure may then be treated as a reason the objection cannot be conclusively established. Secrecy thus protects the assertion of consent from the examination required to assess it.
A public demand for governmental accountability is not a judicial presumption of illegality. A court must determine the applicable law, the relevant evidence, and the burden assigned to each party. That demand does not settle those questions in advance. Nevertheless, the inability to reach a final legal judgment cannot establish that the government’s justification is adequate. An authority claiming to act through another nation’s consent must be able to identify the consent upon which it relies and explain the powers exercised under it. A refusal to supply the necessary documents leaves that justification unexamined, not vindicated.
Article 18 of the Charter of the Organization of American States states that international treaties and agreements should be public. Article 19 prohibits direct or indirect intervention in another state’s internal or external affairs, including interference with its political and economic affairs. Article 20 prohibits economic or political coercion intended to force another state’s sovereign will and obtain advantages. Article 21 declares a state’s territory inviolable, prohibits occupation or other measures of force by another state, and rejects territorial acquisitions or special advantages obtained through force or other coercion. These provisions do not classify every commercial agreement as a treaty or eliminate legitimate exceptions protecting military information. They establish that an announced agreement and the circumstances under which it was obtained are subjects of international responsibility, not matters conclusively determined by the stronger state’s declaration.5
A contract between a government and a private corporation may contain confidential commercial provisions without automatically becoming an international agreement between states. A defense document signed by two governments presents different questions concerning reporting, disclosure, and obligations under international law. But the relevant Venezuelan interests cannot be reduced to the formal classification of either instrument. Both were announced as affecting the conduct of Venezuela’s economic or military affairs. Both require an account of the authority through which Venezuela accepted the obligations attributed to it.
The immediate consequences are borne by Venezuelans who did not participate in the negotiations. Their government may exercise lawful authority on their behalf without obtaining their individual approval of each decision. That is how representative government ordinarily functions. But representation cannot be established solely through the acceptance of the government receiving the benefit of the agreement. Nor can the population’s inability to inspect the terms be treated as acceptance of those terms. The claim to represent public consent calls for particular scrutiny when the officials acting for the nation assumed their positions following foreign military intervention.
The same difficulty reaches Venezuelans who will exercise political authority in the future. A later government may inherit enforceable obligations concluded by its predecessor. The mere election of new officials cannot extinguish those obligations. Yet the nation must have had the lawful capacity to undertake them in the first place, and the circumstances of their conclusion must remain open to examination. The present government’s ability to commit the future cannot derive exclusively from recognition by a foreign power that helped establish the conditions of its rule.
No disclosure of contractual text alone would resolve every question of coercion. The documents may accurately record an agreement while revealing little about threats, pressures, or alternatives considered during negotiation. Other evidence would remain necessary. But withholding the documents eliminates the most immediate means of determining what was accepted, the authority invoked, and the commitments whose acquisition must be examined in relation to the preceding military intervention. The problem cannot be resolved by requiring the public to demonstrate the contents of documents it has been prevented from seeing.
Both governments have presented cooperation as beneficial. Their statements may reflect genuine policy objectives, and some anticipated benefits may eventually materialize. Those possibilities do not establish the independent authority of the Venezuelan nation to determine its own commitments. Economic success cannot retrospectively demonstrate freedom of consent. Military cooperation that produces practical security advantages cannot, by its success, establish the absence of coercion when the agreement was obtained.
A sovereign decision is not established merely because a recognized official performs the act ordinarily associated with making it. The decision must arise from authority the official is entitled to exercise, concern obligations within that authority, and remain subject to the law governing the state’s relations with other powers. Where military force has preceded the agreement, the circumstances of consent require examination in addition to the official’s title. Where the operative document is withheld, the public cannot even begin that examination on equal terms with those claiming the resulting rights.
The two announcements therefore present a contradiction that neither government has publicly resolved. American authority over Venezuelan petroleum is defended through concessions whose operative Venezuelan terms remain unavailable. Military cooperation is defended through a bilateral signature whose operative commitments remain undisclosed. In each case, Venezuela’s consent is invoked to support arrangements affecting sovereign powers, while the Venezuelan people are denied the documents through which they could examine what was authorized in their name.
Coercion under secrecy is not established simply because an agreement has been withheld. It is the condition in which a power that has already used military force invokes the subsequent consent of the state it intervened against while withholding the terms and circumstances necessary to examine that consent. The absence of demonstrated coercion cannot vindicate the agreement when the authorities invoking consent also control the evidence required to test it.
Venezuela’s sovereignty does not depend upon whether Washington acknowledges it. It is not acquired by the officials temporarily occupying governmental office, nor transferred to a foreign power by their signatures. The Venezuelan nation remains the source of the public authority exercised in its name. Those who claim that it has consented must therefore demonstrate what it consented to, who possessed the power to consent, and whether the decision was made under conditions permitting refusal.
A nation cannot be required to prove that its consent was coerced while being denied the means to examine the consent invoked against it. Until those means are supplied, the agreements may establish what the intervening power has obtained. They do not establish what the sovereign nation freely surrendered.
*
Documentary Notes
- November 18, 2026, defense cooperation document. Matthew Adams, “Hegseth makes surprise visit to Venezuela and ‘looks forward’ to deepening military partnership,” Stars and Stripes, November 18, 2026, reproducing the Pentagon’s announcement identifying the signatories and combined-operations purpose. Vivian Sequera, Mayela Armas, and Luis Jaime Acosta, Reuters report, November 18, 2026, recording the public descriptions by Hegseth and Rodríguez. The complete signed agreement was not publicly available in the sources examined as of November 20, 2026.
- Military intervention and subsequent presidential remarks. Donald J. Trump, Truth Social Posts, January 9, 2026, recording his statement that Venezuelan cooperation prompted cancellation of the planned second wave of attacks while American ships remained in position. Donald J. Trump, Remarks During a Meeting With Executives of Oil and Gas Companies and an Exchange With Reporters, January 9, 2026, Daily Compilation of Presidential Documents, recording his subsequent account of the January operation, the contemplated second strike, and the continued naval presence.
- Petroleum agreement and undisclosed Venezuelan concessions. The White House, Fact Sheet: President Donald J. Trump Announces Historic Oil Agreement to Secure American Energy Dominance and Drive Venezuela’s Economic Recovery, August 31, 2026. Cate Brown, Aaron C. Davis, and Sebastian Rotella, “The Secret Terms of Trump’s Venezuelan Oil Deal,” ProPublica, October 20, 2026. The reporting distinguishes the U.S. partnership agreement with NABEP from the underlying Venezuelan concessions, documents provisions protecting the enterprise against future changes, and identifies inconsistencies in the publicly described durations.
- Venezuelan constitutional sovereignty. Constitution of the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela, Articles 5, 7, 12, 150, 154, and 187(11), concerning popular sovereignty and suffrage, constitutional supremacy, public ownership of mineral deposits, legislative approval of qualifying public-interest contracts and treaties, and authorization of foreign military missions.
- International obligations concerning intervention and consent. Charter of the Organization of American States, Articles 18–21, concerning the publicity of international agreements, non-intervention, coercion directed at sovereign will, and advantages obtained through force.








